|
A North Carolina man has become the first person jailed in the US for spamming, despite his attempts to cite the First Amendment. The Virginia Supreme Court upheld a nine year sentence given to Jeremy Jaynes, though only by a 4-3 margin. It's thought he sent ten million spam messages in July and August of 2003 alone, though the original prosecutors only presented evidence of 53,000 messages sent over a three-day period (it's a felony crime to send more than 10,000 spams a day). He was found guilty on three counts, and given a three year-sentence for each. Jaybes was prosecuted in Virginia, where the AOL servers he used were housed.
Though sending unsolicited messages isn't illegal in itself, Jaynes was charged under the 2003 CAN-SPAM act. This requires senders to include a method for recipients to contact them and request they send no further emails. Jaynes did not do this, and used fake email addresses to send the spams. He claimed the laws were unconstitutional because they breached the First Amendment's guarantee of anonymous free speech. He also argued that they illegally restricted his ability to carry out trade across state borders. (Source: informationweek.com) Jaynes' appeal was dismissed because the state's Supreme Court judges ruled that, although the laws could arguably be seen as so broad they unfairly restrict free speech, this didn't apply to purely commercial messages like the ones Jaynes was sending, particularly as some of the content was misleading. They said that to overturn Jaynes' conviction would risk allowing anyone found guilty of misleading commercial activity to use the First Amendment as a get-out clause. Jaynes may now appeal to the national Supreme Court in Washington, DC. (Source: zdnet.com) It's a complicated case, particularly because Jaynes' appeal was largely based on hypothetical arguments. But the main message the judges seem to have given is that free speech laws are no excuse for illegally misleading communication, and that principle still applies online -- to US citizens at least.
-- Related newsletter articles:
2007/09/24 Is it Sick to Buy Drugs from a Spammer? (messages)
2008/02/04 Find all Related Messages: MS Outlook (messages)
2008/01/11 'Mail Store Home', and 'Top 10 Usb Thumb Drive Tricks' (messages)
2007/10/15 RIAA's First Victim to Appeal (appeal)
2007/07/23 Microsoft's Appeal Soon to see a Verdict (appeal)
2007/08/13 Microsoft Updates for August and Everything After (given)
2008/01/21 Amazon Grumbles Over Shipping Law (court)
2007/12/27 Facebook Settles Texting Dispute (messages)
2007/09/06 Dead Ends on the Information Superhighway (laws)
2007/06/01 Microsoft Sues Pump-and-dump Spammers (messages)
2007/12/17 Spam Reaches Record Levels (messages)
2008/02/08 Popular Judge Interrupts Court Proceedings (court)
2006/07/21 Microsoft and Yahoo Messengers Join Forces (messages)
2008/01/29 British Courts Still Targeting Manhunt Game (court)
-- Recent articles (from all channels): 2008/05/09 Today in History: for Friday, May 09, 2008
2008/05/09 [ShellX 20080509]: 'Advanced Run', and 'Diver Windows Manager'
2008/05/09 Texas Refuses Facebook Friend Request
2008/05/09 Photo-Enforcement Technology Replaces Officers On Patrol
2008/05/09 Cuban Government Says 'Ok Computer'
2008/05/09 Excel Can E-Mail Your Weekly Reports For You!
2008/05/08 [ShellX 20080508]: 'Shell Enhancer', and 'Lansweeper'
2008/05/08 Xobni: MS Outlook Social Networking Technology for your Inbox
2008/05/08 Music Companies Jump on GTA IV Bandwagon
2008/05/08 Fascinating: Memristor to replace Binary
2008/05/08 Adobe Hopes To Make Flash Master Of The (Mobile) Universe
2008/05/08 Spiffy Envelopes and Labels in MS Word
2008/05/07 [ShellX 20080507]: 'Winbin2iso', and 'Loop Typer'
2008/05/07 Yahoo Adds Security Warnings To Search Results
2008/05/07 Apple to Lose Money on iTunes Movie Releases
2008/05/07 Amazon.com takes New York Tax to Court
2008/05/07 Need Glasses for the Slide Sorter View in MS PowerPoint?
2008/05/07 After Winning The DVD Format War, Blu-Ray Sales Tank
2008/05/06 [ShellX 20080506]: 'Visual Basic 6.0 Portable', and 'Double-...
2008/05/06 Yahoo Outsources to Jajah
2008/05/06 New HP Circuit Could Change Technology Forever
2008/05/06 Movie Downloads To Match DVD Release Dates
2008/05/06 Microsoft Ends Yahoo Bid
2008/05/05 [ShellX 20080505]: 'Ie7 Pro', and 'Desktop Ok'
2008/05/05 The WB Network Hops Online
2008/05/05 Microsoft Slashes Price of Xbox 360 Overseas
2008/05/05 Google CEO Wants YouTube to Take More of Your Money
2008/05/05 Finding Items in MS Outlook's Reading Pane
2008/05/02 [ShellX 20080502]: 'Software Virtualization Solution', and '...
2008/05/02 Rogers Brings iPhone to Canada
2008/05/02 New Google Tool Cuts Down Irrelevant Image Search Results
|
