|
The defendant found guilty of file-sharing in her case against the Record Industry Association of America (RIAA) has decided to appeal. Hey, if you were a single mother facing a $222,000 fine, what would you do? The decision stems from the story I reported a few days ago, in which one Jammie Thomas was staring down the full weight of the RIAA. Since then, Thomas has been found guilty and ordered to pay the $200,000-plus fine, representing almost ten thousand dollars for each of the 24 songs she illegally downloaded and shared on now-defunct protocol Kazaa. (Source: pcworld.com)
The RIAA represents the whole of the recording industry in legal cases like these. In this instance, the body was speaking on behalf of Capitol Records Inc., Sony BMG Music Entertainment, and Warner Bros. Records Inc. It's fair to say Thomas, the first file-sharer brought to trial, has been sacrificed for the message it sends to others engaged in similar activity. Her 24 shared songs represents a number so small on the radar that the RIAA can't possibly believe it has advanced its grandiose mission. That's why Thomas may have a shot through her appeal. In addition, lawyers for the RIAA have only proven that she "made available" songs for download on Kazaa, with no proof (as yet) that anyone actually took advantage. If Thomas' lawyer, Brian Toder, can force the RIAA to make this clearer to a judge, the defendant's chances improve. (Source: news.com) At the heart of the appeal will be the "made available" concept. Since it's tough to prove anyone is aware that they've made files available for sharing, the appeal decision could have major ramifications. A sustained guilty judgment would set the RIAA off on a wreckless crusade; it'd be like matching up a prize fighter with the asthmatic kid from algebra. No fair.
-- Related newsletter articles:
2007/08/09 Cell Phones Selling Indie Music? (songs)
2007/07/23 Microsoft's Appeal Soon to see a Verdict (appeal)
2007/10/10 RIAA Begins Courtroom Crusade (thomas)
2007/10/10 Microsoft's "Rock n' Chat" Revolution! (songs)
-- Recent articles (from all channels): 2008/05/12 Today in History: for Monday, May 12, 2008
2008/05/12 [ShellX 20080512]: 'Remote Manager', and 'Cyber Bandwidth ...
2008/05/12 Video Gaming Trade Group Struggling
2008/05/12 T-Mobile Finally Joins 3G Phone Race
2008/05/12 Apple Slammed by Environment Watchdog
2008/05/09 [ShellX 20080509]: 'Advanced Run', and 'Diver Windows Manager'
2008/05/09 Texas Refuses Facebook Friend Request
2008/05/09 Photo-Enforcement Technology Replaces Officers On Patrol
2008/05/09 Cuban Government Says 'Ok Computer'
2008/05/09 Excel Can E-Mail Your Weekly Reports For You!
2008/05/08 [ShellX 20080508]: 'Shell Enhancer', and 'Lansweeper'
2008/05/08 Xobni: MS Outlook Social Networking Technology for your Inbox
2008/05/08 Music Companies Jump on GTA IV Bandwagon
2008/05/08 Fascinating: Memristor to replace Binary
2008/05/08 Adobe Hopes To Make Flash Master Of The (Mobile) Universe
2008/05/08 Spiffy Envelopes and Labels in MS Word
2008/05/07 [ShellX 20080507]: 'Winbin2iso', and 'Loop Typer'
2008/05/07 Yahoo Adds Security Warnings To Search Results
2008/05/07 Apple to Lose Money on iTunes Movie Releases
2008/05/07 Amazon.com takes New York Tax to Court
2008/05/07 Need Glasses for the Slide Sorter View in MS PowerPoint?
2008/05/07 After Winning The DVD Format War, Blu-Ray Sales Tank
2008/05/06 [ShellX 20080506]: 'Visual Basic 6.0 Portable', and 'Double-...
2008/05/06 Yahoo Outsources to Jajah
2008/05/06 New HP Circuit Could Change Technology Forever
2008/05/06 Movie Downloads To Match DVD Release Dates
2008/05/06 Microsoft Ends Yahoo Bid
2008/05/05 [ShellX 20080505]: 'Ie7 Pro', and 'Desktop Ok'
2008/05/05 The WB Network Hops Online
2008/05/05 Microsoft Slashes Price of Xbox 360 Overseas
2008/05/05 Google CEO Wants YouTube to Take More of Your Money
|
