Internet Piracy Warning Program Ditched
A controversial program of warning letters for suspected copyright infringers has been dropped. The organization behind it says it was a successful education program but critics say it failed to have much impact.
The "Copyright Alert System" was set up by the Center for Copyright Information, made up of the main producers of TV shows, movies and music in the US. It struck a deal in 2013 with the five largest Internet providers to send up to six warnings to customers after the copyright holders made a complaint of alleged infringement.
The precise format was up to the Internet firm, but the main principle was that the first two messages were simply warnings, the next two required the customer to formally acknowledge having read the message (or lose Internet access until they did so) and the final two would be accompanied by minor sanctions such as slowed speeds.
More Than a Million Warnings Sent
At first it appeared the system was acting as a deterrent. One estimate said that in the first 10 months of the program, 1.3 million people got a first warning, but the numbers for each follow-up dropped and just 37,456 people got the sixth warning.
The Center for Copyright Information says it is dropping the program but notes it "demonstrated that real progress is possible when content creators, Internet innovators and consumer advocates come together in a collaborative and consensus-driven process. CAS succeeded in educating many people about the availability of legal content, as well as about issues associated with online infringement." (Source: copyrightinformation.org)
Hardcore Pirates Undeterred
However, the chief lawyer at the Movie Picture Association of America (MPAA) said the system hadn't really worked, mainly because it turned out that a lot of piracy is down to a "hard-core repeat infringer problem." In other words, the people who do the most piracy know full well they are breaking the law and don't take much notice of even repeated warnings (Source: variety.com)
One big problem with the program appears to be that Internet providers are very wary about cutting off customers for piracy: not just because it means losing business, but because the IP numbers provided as proof of piracy by copyright holders are far from a perfect way of confirming that a particular individual did indeed share or copy files online.
IP addresses are poor indicators of piracy for a number of reasons. First, the use of anonymous virtual private networks (VPNs) make it almost impossible to determine where the originating IP address resides - that's because a VPN essentially acts like a relay. Secondly, IP addresses are leased by Internet providers. That means a specific IP is not chained to a particular computer all the time; instead, they expire after a duration of time (by the Internet provider), they change during a power outage, and they also change if the user unplugs the modem on purpose.
What's Your Opinion?
Are you surprised the program didn't work as well as might have been hoped? Are warnings enough to deter online pirates? Is there an effective but reliable way that copyright holders can tackle piracy?
Infopackets Top Windows 10 FAQs
How to Upgrade from Windows 10 32-bit to 64-bit
How to Fix: Windows 10 Antivirus Missing, Not Compatible
How to Fix: Windows 10 Display Shifted; Screen Fuzzy
How to Upgrade Windows 7, 8 32-bit to Windows 10 64-bit
to Downgrade from Windows 10
- How to Fix: Windows 10 Upgrade Failed Error C1900208
- How to Fix: Windows 10 Upgrade Failed Error 80240020
- Can I Cancel my Windows 10 Reservation and Reserve Later?
- How to Clean Install Windows 10 using Windows 7, 8 License
- Will Windows 10 Install Automatically?
- Windows 10 Upgrade: Do I have to Reinstall Programs?
- Windows 10 Upgrade: Can I choose 32-bit or 64-bit?
- Which Version of Windows 10 Will I Get (Home or Pro)?
- How to Reserve Windows 10 Upgrade (Free)
- How to Fix: CPU Not Compatible with Windows 10 Error
- Windows 10 Upgrade: Can I keep my Old Windows Install?
- How to Cancel Windows 10 Reservation (Properly)
- Download Windows 10 .ISO (DVD) for Clean Install?
- Microsoft: Windows 10 Will Be The Last Version
- Does Windows 10 require the CPU to support PAE?
- Windows 10: Can I Upgrade or do I need a Clean Install?
Click here for more Windows 10 articles.