Explained: How and Why Windows Goes Corrupt

Dennis Faas's picture

I've been repairing computers now for over 23 years and for the last few years, I began offering my computer repair service online. One of the most popular repairs I do today is to fix Windows Update; sometimes, however, Windows Update is too far corrupt that it requires a complete reinstall of Windows in order to fix the issue. The same can be said in other situations where Windows is too far corrupt that it cannot be repaired even by someone with as much experience as I have. Based on this, users ask me "Why is my Windows corrupt?" and "How can this have happened?" I thought I'd write an article explaining various ways Windows can go corrupt. Note that the list below is not exhaustive, but will certainly shed some light.

Loss of Power and Improper Shutdowns

One of the easiest ways to corrupt Windows is to lose power to the computer (especially while it's updating, for example). In a case like this, system files may in the process of being updated; if the process does not complete 100%, what you end up with mismatched or corrupted binary files. The same can be said if you do not shut down the system properly (by clicking Start, then shutdown). Oftentimes the system will be updating itself in some way or another (even if it's not explicitly stating so); if you shut down without properly notifying all programs of the impending shutdown, you stand a chance of corrupting files. Most of the time, files can be corrected by scanning the drive for errors, however, this does not always work and then strange things start to happen.

Antivirus Software Conflicts with Windows

It's a well documented fact that Antivirus software can conflict with Windows Updates, which can corrupt the system to the point Windows won't even boot, or it might break certain parts of Windows entirely. For example, I've personally witnessed Antivirus software interfering with parts of Windows that prevented the Windows Start menu from functioning. The only way to get it back was to disable the antivirus, then initiate some patch work (using the Power Shell) to reinstate / reinstall broken Windows Services, however, this does not always work.

A Bad or Failed Windows Update

It's also a well documented fact that Microsoft has released Windows Updates in the past that have then caused Windows to break. Sometimes it's parts of Windows that stop functioning properly (certain services) or strange bugs will appear, or the system may go completely corrupt to the point where you need to reinstall Windows. I have personally witnessed on my own machine a Windows Update that appeared to have wiped out my master boot record. This caused the machine to freeze just before booting into Windows. The only way to fix it was to restore a backup.

Registry Cleaners and System Optimizers

Some (most) "registry cleaners" and "system optimizers" are pure snake oil. They promise to "clean" the system, but instead make things worse by deleting registry entries or modifying Windows services that should not have been modified or deleted in the first place, which then causes Windows to corrupt. Another thing many "system optimizers" do is stay resident in memory (in the background), which then scans all activity on the computer, which then slows you down even more. It's completely unnecessary. My advice is that you steer clear of these programs - Windows works just fine 9 times out of 10 on its own. If your computer is slow and you want to address a specific issue, hire a professional to go in and look at it and tell you why and how to fix it properly.

Remnants of a Malware or Virus Attack

Oftentimes, malware and viruses will attack operating system files in an attempt to infect files and hide itself so that it can stay resident in memory. Unfortunately not all antivirus and antimalware programs can clean infected files 100% of the time. What you end up with is a system that is half clean, somewhat operational, but corrupt due to an infection that was not removed properly. In cases like this the only way out is to backup and reinstall Windows.

Hardware Failures

In rare cases there are hardware failures which can corrupt system files, but most of the time a hardware failure results in system instability, either way you look at it. For example, the system might be completely fine for a few hours and then all the sudden it will act erratic and freeze up. The only way "out" is to forcibly power off the system in order to reboot it, but as I mentioned previously, unclean shutdowns like this can also lead to corrupt operating system files. Aside from that: if the system is not stable, the only way to diagnose a hardware failure is to do a clean install of Windows, anyway, then perform various tests on hardware through process of elimination. Some users may use various methods for testing hardware, but it depends on what the problem is. 9 times out of 10 a clean reinstall of Windows is necessary.

There are other reasons why Windows can go corrupt, but these are probably the most popular. I hope this helps.

Got a Computer Question or Problem? Ask Dennis!

I need more computer questions. If you have a computer question - or even a computer problem that needs fixing - please email me with your question so that I can write more articles like this one. I can't promise I'll respond to all the messages I receive (depending on the volume), but I'll do my best.

About the author: Dennis Faas is the owner and operator of Infopackets.com. With over 30 years of computing experience, Dennis' areas of expertise are a broad range and include PC hardware, Microsoft Windows, Linux, network administration, and virtualization. Dennis holds a Bachelors degree in Computer Science (1999) and has authored 6 books on the topics of MS Windows and PC Security. If you like the advice you received on this page, please up-vote / Like this page and share it with friends. For technical support inquiries, Dennis can be reached via Live chat online this site using the Zopim Chat service (currently located at the bottom left of the screen); optionally, you can contact Dennis through the website contact form.

Rate this article: 
Average: 4.5 (15 votes)

Comments

Sparkydog's picture

I've been in the computer field for about 30 years, and repairing computers for close to the same time as you.
I would say that FREE registry checkers and optimizers are a problem, as well as FREE antivirus applications.
Most of the time, I can do a "Repair Install" instead of totally reloading. This saves the user's files, as well as settings.
I have never understood why MS never fixed the problem of restarting the update process, in case of a power failure, as well as automatically reverting to an earlier driver, upon running into an incompatible driver.
Anyhow, thank you for providing this newsletter. It is a great source of information and news.
I have not converted to Windows 10, for personal, biased reasons, but one of my daughters has. I, sometimes, forward one of your Windows 10 stories to her.
When and if the time comes for me to convert, I am comforted by the fact that I can access your archived stories and "how-to's."

scowei's picture

All these years of optimizing my system every month or so, feeling all superior about doing it. Just uninstalled that program. Thanks.

Rusty's picture

Excellent and well informed advice as always, Dennis. I'd venture to say that nearly all of us slightly above average users are doing things and maybe paying money for utilities that are more likely to cause harm than do good. It's sometimes difficult for us to embrace expert assessment that calls into question inaccurate preconceived notions and "traditional wisdom" about Windows and computers in general. It was good to learn from you that having the proper backups in place will make any required Windows reinstallation go more smoothly than I ever dreamed possible. Hopefully and with a little luck, it will never come to that, but it's comforting to know it's not the end of the world if it does. Earlier this year, I hired you to spend a few hours to help me with an upgrade and provide overall advice about my system. As time goes on, I am further appreciating the tremendous value of what you did for me. It pretty clearly has already paid for itself. Thank you so much!

caseymcpoet's picture

Hi Dennis: This makes sense. As I previously wrote to you my HP Netbook 'died' after a windows update a month ago. I had previously updated my HP Notebook to Windows 10 with very few glitches. It seemed like it would be the same. However after the 1st windows update on the Netbook I clicked for a restart. Unfortunately it refused to boot. I tried every solution I could find, even trying to default to the Windows 7 Starter it came with. I have yet to pull the HD & put it into an enclosure to see what I can salvage. However I also came across on the web a remark that MS had a Win 10 Tech site for issues like mine. Do you know if there is such a site? Thanks

pctyson's picture

A memory check confirmed what I eventually suspected, after weeks of diagnosing. I had a flaky memory module that was corrupting the files on the disk and causing random problems. These were just random enough for me to not originally suspect memory at all. I have never had a memory module go bad before in over 20 years of computing. I removed the memory, reinstalled Windows 10, and voila. All problems went away. I was also able to perform the Windows updates after removing the faulty memory and the random problems disappeared.